Do You Leave Burlap on Tree When Planting?

If you're planning on planting a tree or have recently done so, you may have come across the question of whether or not to remove the burlap from around the tree's root ball. Some argue that it's important to remove the burlap to allow the tree's roots to grow freely, while others claim that leaving it on can actually prevent transplant shock and promote healthy growth. So, which is the best approach? Let's take a closer look.

The Case for Removing Burlap

Those in favor of removing burlap from a newly planted tree argue that it can impede the growth of the tree's root system. Burlap is typically made from natural fibers that will eventually decompose, but this process can take years. During that time, the burlap can restrict the movement of the roots, preventing them from reaching out and establishing themselves in the surrounding soil. Over time, this can lead to stunted growth and potentially even tree failure.

Additionally, the burlap used in tree planting is often treated with various chemicals to prevent rot and promote longevity. While these treatments may be effective in extending the life of the burlap, they can also be harmful to the tree's health if they come in contact with its roots.

The Case for Leaving Burlap

On the other hand, some experts argue that leaving burlap on a newly planted tree can actually benefit its growth. When a tree is transplanted, it undergoes a period of shock as it adjusts to its new surroundings. This shock can cause the tree to struggle with the transfer of water and nutrients from its roots to the rest of its system. By keeping the burlap on, it can create a barrier that helps to retain moisture, making it easier for the tree to establish itself.

Additionally, some burlap materials are made from natural fabrics that will decompose over time. As the burlap breaks down, it can actually provide nutrients to the surrounding soil, giving the tree an additional boost as it grows.

The Final Verdict

So, which approach is best? Ultimately, it depends on the specific circumstances of your tree planting. If you're dealing with burlap that is treated with harmful chemicals, it's always best to remove it to avoid damaging your tree's roots. However, if the burlap is made from natural fibers and poses no threat to the tree's health, leaving it on may be the better option.

Another factor to consider is the type of soil you're planting in. If you're dealing with extremely dry or sandy soil, leaving the burlap on can help to retain moisture and create a more hospitable environment for your tree to grow in.

Ultimately, the most important thing is to take care when planting your tree, making sure that it's positioned correctly and watered properly in the days and weeks following planting. With the right care and attention, your newly planted tree should grow strong and healthy, regardless of whether or not the burlap is left on.