Introduction

One of the most important decisions one has to make when planting a tree is determining whether or not to remove the burlap from the root ball prior to planting. There are varying opinions on this matter and it can be confusing for gardeners, particularly beginners, to make the right decision. This article aims to provide insight into whether or not the burlap should be removed when planting a tree.

The Case Against Burlap Removal

Advocates of burlap leave it on the root ball because it serves as a protective layer for the roots, preventing them from drying out while the tree is being transported from the nursery to its new location. In addition, burlap is biodegradable and will decompose over time, enriching the soil surrounding the tree. Some gardeners also recommend leaving the wire basket and twine that may be wrapped around the root ball as they can add structural support and help anchor the tree in place. Removing these items, according to this viewpoint, could damage the roots and harm the tree.

The Case for Burlap Removal

Many horticulturalists believe that burlap should be removed when planting a tree. They argue that burlap, along with any other synthetic materials, can impede the growth of the tree's roots and limit its access to valuable nutrients and moisture. Additionally, while burlap is biodegradable, it does not break down quickly enough to prevent it from smothering the roots and restricting their growth. Some gardeners also argue that leaving the wire basket and twine in place can lead to the roots circling back on themselves, resulting in a stunted and poorly developed root system.

Compromise

Ultimately, the decision to remove or leave the burlap and wire basket in place is dependent on a variety of factors such as the type of tree being planted, the condition of the burlap and wire, and the preferences of the gardener. One compromise solution would be to loosen the burlap, allowing it to decompose more quickly while still serving as a protective layer during initial planting. The wire basket could also be removed, but the twine could be left in place to provide added structural support. It is important to note that if the tree appears to be root-bound, where the roots have grown in a tight circle around the root ball, the burlap and wire basket should be completely removed as they may be contributing to the issue.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the decision to remove or leave the burlap and wire basket in place when planting a tree remains a debatable one. While some gardeners swear by leaving it in place, others argue that it is detrimental to the tree's growth. Ultimately, it is up to the gardener to make a decision based on the particular circumstances of their planting site and personal preferences. Regardless of the decision made, it is important to ensure that the tree is properly planted and cared for to ensure its long-term success.