Should Skin on Paperwhites be Removed Before Planting in Water?

Paperwhites are beautiful and fragrant flowers that provide a pop of color and a sweet aroma to any indoor space. Many gardeners choose to grow paperwhites in water rather than soil, but there is often a debate about whether or not to remove the skin before planting. In this article, we will explore both sides of the argument and provide a definitive answer to this question.

The Case for Removing the Skin

One argument for removing the skin on paperwhites before planting is that it can improve the growth and health of the plant. The skin is the brown coating that covers the bulb, and it can inhibit the transfer of nutrients and moisture through the bulb. Without the skin, the bulb can more easily absorb these important elements and grow stronger roots and foliage.

Another benefit of removing the skin is that it can prevent fungal infections and other diseases. The skin can provide a moist environment that is ideal for the growth of harmful fungi and bacteria. By removing the skin, you can prevent these pathogens from taking hold and damaging your plant.

Reasons to Keep the Skin

Despite these potential benefits, there are some reasons why you might want to keep the skin on your paperwhites. The main argument for leaving the skin intact is that it can help to protect the bulb from damage. When the bulb is exposed to light, it can trigger premature growth that can weaken the plant and cause it to bloom too soon or too small.

Additionally, some gardeners believe that leaving the skin on can help the plant to retain more moisture over time. This can be especially important if you live in a dry or arid environment, where the plant may not get enough hydration from the surrounding air or soil.

The Verdict

So, should you remove the skin on paperwhites before planting in water? The answer is...it depends!

If you are growing paperwhites in a dark or low-light environment, it may be best to leave the skin on to prevent premature growth. However, if you are growing in a well-lit area and want to promote strong root development, removing the skin may be the way to go.

Ultimately, the decision should be based on your specific situation and the needs of your plant. Experiment with both approaches to see which works best for you, and don't be afraid to make adjustments as needed.

Additional Tips for Growing Paperwhites

No matter whether you choose to remove the skin or keep it on, there are a few tips that can help your paperwhites thrive:

Choose a container that is tall and narrow, with room for the bulbs to grow down and out

Use distilled or filtered water, as tap water can contain minerals and chemicals that can harm the plant

Keep the water level consistent, adding more as needed to keep the bulb roots moist but not submerged

Place the container in a sunny or well-lit location, but avoid direct sunlight or high heat

By following these tips and choosing the right approach for your needs, you can enjoy beautiful, healthy paperwhites that brighten up any space.